It starts with a swastika.
Not on a wall. On a Zoom screen.
A Jewish student logs in to a lecture, only to be met with Nazi slogans scrawled across the shared whiteboard. It’s 2024. This is Australia.
The government says it’s had enough. In a move making headlines, Canberra is now eyeing funding cuts for universities that fail to tackle antisemitism on campus. Student visa scrutiny may follow for foreign nationals involved in hate speech or harassment.
Some call it necessary. Others call it a distraction.
But here’s what nobody seems to agree on: Who’s actually doing the harassing?
The Numbers Are Real. The Profile Is Murkier.
Let’s be clear—antisemitism is on the rise in Australia.
According to the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, reported antisemitic incidents more than tripled in the last year—from social media threats to physical violence. That’s not hysteria. That’s data.
But when politicians or pundits try to answer the “who”, the conversation gets blurry—fast.
Some headlines point fingers at pro-Palestinian student groups—especially after the October 7 attacks in Israel. Others point to a rise in far-right extremism online. Still others blame “imported hatreds” from migrant communities—code, often, for Muslims.
So is it mostly Muslim students?
White supremacists?
Keyboard warriors?
The truth is: it’s all of the above—and more.
It’s Not Just Muslims. It’s Also the Usual Suspects.
Yes, some antisemitic harassment has come from self-described Muslim students at protests, particularly during heated moments in the Israel-Palestine conflict. Some of it is driven by rage, some by ignorance, and some by imported Middle Eastern conspiracy theories that don’t belong anywhere, let alone in a liberal democracy.
But to reduce the problem to “Muslim mobs” is not just inaccurate—it’s politically convenient.
Because white nationalist groups in Australia have long been a core source of antisemitism. They’re the ones plastering suburbs with Nazi symbols. They’re the ones circulating Holocaust denial on Telegram. Their ideology didn’t arrive with refugees—it’s homegrown, and it's thriving.
Then there are the fringe conspiracy theorists—anti-vaxxers turned QAnon believers turned “globalist” truthers—who slide effortlessly from anti-government rants to antisemitic tropes about Rothschilds, Zionists, and world domination.
And finally, yes, some hard-left activists on university campuses have crossed the line from anti-Zionism into outright antisemitism—calling Jewish students “genocide apologists” or defacing Jewish centers with red paint and slurs.
It’s a spectrum. Not a single source.
Will Visa Crackdowns and Defunding Fix It?
Here’s where it gets messy.
Cutting university funding if administrators fail to stop antisemitism might sound strong. But what does “failing” even mean? Who decides? If a student puts up a poster that offends another, is that grounds for defunding an entire institution?
Visa checks for foreign students involved in hate speech? Reasonable—if applied fairly and legally. But let’s not pretend hate speech only comes from outsiders. Many of the worst offenders in online spaces are Australian-born, white, and fluent in Reddit dog whistles.
We want protection for Jewish students. We should demand it. But we should also ask: Are we solving the problem, or scapegoating certain groups to look decisive?
What If We’re Asking the Wrong Question?
Instead of constantly asking “Who’s to blame?”, maybe we should ask:
-
Why are universities so bad at dealing with hate, full stop?
-
Why are Muslim and Jewish students pitted against each other when many actually want peaceful coexistence?
-
Why do we think security crackdowns fix what empathy and education could prevent?
In a diverse country like Australia, antisemitism can come from any corner—right, left, religious, secular, foreign-born, or native. Pretending otherwise doesn’t just miss the mark. It risks making things worse.
Maybe the swastika on Zoom wasn’t the first sign. Maybe it was the silence that followed.
And maybe what Jewish students want isn’t just protection—but honesty.
Not panic. Not tokenism.
Just a real reckoning with where the hate is coming from—and who’s willing to stop it.
Post a Comment