When Nations Built on Dreams Leave Their People Behind
> “We came here for freedom. What we got was a mortgage, military drills, and meltdowns.”
— David, Israeli expat in London
Every nation has a story it tells itself.
America has the Dream.
France has the Republic.
India calls itself the world’s largest democracy.
And Israel?
Israel was the Promised Land—a sanctuary, a mission, a miracle.
But what happens when the dream doesn’t hold?
When the chosen place starts feeling like a burden?
This isn’t just about Israel.
It’s about every country built on an ideal—struggling to live up to it.
Israel’s Founding Story: A Nation Reborn
Israel’s birth in 1948 wasn’t just geopolitical—it was spiritual.
A place for Jews to be safe. To flourish. To finally live without fear.
Its early years were a whirlwind of survival and socialist idealism—kibbutzim, community halls, Hebrew poetry, Holocaust survivors turning deserts into farms.
It wasn’t perfect. But it was sacred.
Over time, Israel became a startup powerhouse, a military titan, a global brand. But in the process, many argue, it lost its soul.
The Exodus No One Talks About
Today, tens of thousands of Israelis are quietly leaving.
Not because of rockets. Not because of antisemitism.
But because the country no longer feels like a home worth fighting for.
> In 2023, over 40,000 Israelis emigrated permanently.
That’s a 60% increase compared to five years ago.
Many are highly educated—engineers, doctors, artists.
The very people who could build the future are choosing to leave it behind.
Why?
Because apartments cost over $1 million, salaries haven’t kept pace, and life feels like a daily grind of taxes, traffic, and tension.
The Promised Land feels... over-promised.
Pakistan: Another Nation, Another Myth
Now zoom out.
Pakistan was founded in 1947—around the same time as Israel—with another grand vision: a homeland for South Asian Muslims.
Jinnah dreamed of a modern, tolerant, democratic state.
Today, many Pakistanis can’t recognize that dream.
Just like Israel, Pakistan is losing its best and brightest.
> In 2022, over 765,000 Pakistanis left the country—
including 92,000 professionals: doctors, engineers, IT specialists.
By mid-2023, the number rose to 832,000, with brain drain hitting an all-time high.
The reasons echo Israel's:
Economic collapse
Joblessness
Political disillusionment
Broken infrastructure
Lost hope
Why Do Nations Lose Their Way?
Because ideals don’t maintain themselves.
Because democracy is not self-cleaning.
Because promises need care, accountability, and love.
Both Israel and Pakistan were born of trauma, carved out by war, held together by myth.
But myths crack when rent is unaffordable, when talent is wasted, when your children are anxious, and your job doesn’t pay enough to dream.
> “We didn’t leave our countries.
Our countries left us.”
— A Pakistani nurse in Qatar
The Brain Drain is a Heart Drain
Losing professionals isn’t just economic.
It’s emotional.
A slow bleeding of hope, of community, of identity.
The teacher who moves to Germany leaves behind a generation of students.
The software engineer who builds apps in Canada could’ve built schools back home.
The doctor who serves in the Gulf was trained on taxpayer money in Karachi or Tel Aviv.
And what replaces them?
Often silence. Or worse—cynicism.
-
The Future Is Not Inevitable
No country is doomed to fail.
But no dream survives on inertia.
To recover their promise, nations must:
Make life livable for their middle class
Invest in healthcare, housing, and education
Reduce corruption and polarization
Listen to those who feel invisible
Invite their expats home—not with slogans, but with solutions
Until then, the exodus will continue.
> The tragedy of a broken country isn’t just the people who leave—
It’s the ones who stay, and stop believing.
Post a Comment