A cross shattered, and suddenly the world noticed.
For months, Gaza has been a graveyard of silenced outrage. Mosques destroyed. Schools turned to rubble. Tents full of families reduced to ash. And yet—no European prime minister raised their voice.
Until now.
It wasn’t the bombed hospitals or the 58,000 lives claimed by the war that broke the silence. It was a Catholic church. One church. Struck in the Holy Land.
Italy’s far-right Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, once a staunch ally of Israel, finally rebuked Netanyahu’s government. Why this, and why now?
Maybe the answer lies in the West’s enduring double standard—and in what it chooses to grieve.
“No military action can justify this.”
On Friday, Gaza’s civil defense agency confirmed what had long been feared: the Holy Family Church in Gaza City had been hit. Two dead. Several wounded. Among them, Father Gabriel Romanelli, a parish priest closely connected to the late Pope Francis.
The church wasn’t a military base. It wasn’t a command center. It was a shelter for over 500 displaced Christians and Muslims, huddled together under its roof.
But it burned.
While Israel denies targeting religious sites, the images are hard to explain away. And this time, something shifted.
Italy—a proudly Catholic nation—felt the impact. Giorgia Meloni, whose government has backed Israel unequivocally for months, declared:
“The attacks against the civilian population that Israel has been carrying out for months are unacceptable. No military action can justify such behavior.”
Her words were not subtle. They weren’t hedged. For the first time since October 7, a major Western leader spoke of Israel’s actions in Gaza with moral clarity.
But mosques have been bombed too. Where was the outrage then?
This wasn’t the first religious site destroyed. Over 100 mosques have been leveled since the war began. Imams have died with Qurans pressed to their chests. Islamic schools, libraries, and cemeteries have all faced Israeli airstrikes.
But these attacks were met with shrugs—or worse, silence.
It took a Catholic church, with a priest tied to the Vatican, for that silence to break.
And this says something painful about the Western gaze: its outrage is selective. Its empathy often stops where its cultural mirrors end.
Why do mosques not elicit the same urgency?
Why did no European leader mourn the children killed in UN-run schools or the families burned alive in refugee camps?
These aren’t rhetorical questions. They’re indictments of a geopolitical order that categorizes pain—and decides which lives are too foreign to matter.
The Vatican’s voice: soft, sorrowful, and too late
The Vatican issued a telegram of condolence. Cardinal Pietro Parolin, the Holy See’s Secretary of State, quoted Pope Francis:
“He was deeply saddened to learn of the loss of life… and expressed closeness to Reverend Gabriel Romanelli and the entire parish.”
The Pope renewed his call for a ceasefire and for dialogue. But those calls feel like prayers whispered into a hurricane. And for many, they come too late.
What about the Muslims in Gaza? The starving? The bombed-out shelters? Did they not deserve this same spiritual solidarity?
What it took for the West to flinch
A single church. Two Christian bodies. A priest beloved in Rome.
That’s what it took to shift the narrative—even slightly. That’s what it took to get a European leader to say, finally, “this is not okay.”
But the war didn’t start with that church. It didn’t peak with that strike. Over 58,000 Gazans are dead, and nearly half of Gaza’s population is displaced. Whole families have been wiped from civil registries.
And yet, only now does the West blink.
So maybe that’s the real tragedy.
Not just that a church was bombed—but that it took a Christian body to shake Europe’s conscience.
And maybe that's the problem.
Post a Comment