He said it out loud.
“The army must find ways more painful than death for the civilians in Gaza. Killing them is not enough.”
Those weren’t the words of some rogue internet troll. They came from Amichai Eliyahu—the Israeli Heritage Minister. A man entrusted with preserving the soul and story of a people. Instead, he spat venom with the weight of state power behind him.
And yet, somehow, we’re expected to call this civilization. Chosenness. Divine favor.
But what kind of God chooses cruelty?
When Heritage Is Hollowed Out by Hatred
Amichai Eliyahu’s remarks weren’t a slip. They were an ideology speaking without its mask.
To say “killing is not enough” and that “more painful” methods should be found—for civilians—is not just a war crime in spirit, it’s a desecration of every Jewish teaching that once warned against this very thing.
Remember: Israel claims to be a democracy. Its leaders are educated, multilingual, backed by Western allies. But this is not the language of democracy. It’s the lexicon of the Inquisition, of the Gestapo, of those who believed that some suffering was too merciful.
Here’s what I noticed: when Palestinians resist, they are called terrorists. But when an Israeli minister openly advocates torture or annihilation of civilians, the world shrugs. White House silence. EU shrugs. A press statement, maybe. But no sanctions. No ICC arrest warrant. No trials in The Hague.
God’s Chosen—or War’s Chosen?
What kind of heritage is this?
Amichai Eliyahu holds the title of Heritage Minister—the keeper of cultural memory, the steward of historical values. The man should be preserving art, poetry, tombstones, traditions. Instead, he’s dreaming up horrors “worse than death” for Gazan children, parents, and elders.
This is how state power rots from the inside—when the ministries of memory become engines of hate. When “heritage” is no longer a story of survival but a blueprint for subjugation.
And yes, it stings to hear it wrapped in the language of Jewish identity.
As a Muslim, I’ve been taught not to mock “the people of the book.” I’ve admired Jewish philosophers, Jewish humor, Jewish resilience. But what Amichai said isn’t Judaism—it’s fascism wearing a kippah.
But Maybe the Silence Says More
You ever wonder why the world lets this pass?
Why ministers like Eliyahu aren’t forced to resign?
Why international media won’t touch this statement unless someone else dies to make it newsworthy?
Maybe it’s because we’ve all become numb. Maybe we’ve started to believe that some people deserve suffering. That Gaza is too messy, too brown, too Muslim to matter.
Or maybe—and this is worse—we’re just cowards. Afraid to speak because it might cost us a friendship, a visa, a job at a think tank.
But if this is what Israel’s “heritage” ministers are preaching, then something is deeply, fundamentally broken. Not just in Israel. But in the conscience of every nation that keeps nodding along.
Final Thought: Who Speaks for the Soul of a People?
Not every Israeli supports this. Many Jewish voices—brave, defiant—have spoken out. But how many are heard?
Amichai Eliyahu claims to be the guardian of Jewish memory.
But if this is what memory looks like now—calls for pain worse than death—then maybe forgetting would be holier.
Then again, maybe silence says enough.
Post a Comment