Part 1 of “The Forgotten Exodus: Jews from Muslim Lands”
A dusty stone reads: Rachel Sopher, 1918.
It lies alone in the crumbling Jewish cemetery off M.A. Jinnah Road. Few people notice it. Fewer still know what it means. But once, there was a vibrant Jewish community in Karachi. Today, it’s a ghost.
We were taught that Jews lived only in Israel or the West. No one told us they were once our neighbors — raising families, building schools, praying in synagogues that now no longer exist.
What happened?
A Community Hiding in Plain Sight
Before Partition, Karachi’s Jews lived largely in Saddar and Bunder Road. They were mostly Bene Israel Jews, originally from India, who had come during British rule. Some had roots in Baghdad or Persia. They spoke Marathi, Urdu, Hebrew, English.
They built lives as teachers, musicians, watchmakers, traders. There was no ghetto, no segregation. They walked freely among Christians, Hindus, Parsis, and Muslims. Their synagogue, Magain Shalome, built in 1893, was a proud landmark.
Jews even worked in government. Abraham Reuben served as a councilor in the Karachi Municipal Corporation in the 1930s. This wasn’t just coexistence. It was community.
Then Came the Fire
The turning point was 1947–48. The creation of Israel and the ensuing Arab-Israeli war ignited a political fury far from the battlefield.
-
In 1948, anti-Jewish riots broke out in Karachi. Magain Shalome was attacked. Jewish homes and businesses were stoned or burned.
-
The Pakistani government, though not officially banning Judaism, watched silently. That silence gave permission to rage.
-
Synagogues came under surveillance. The Jewish school had to close.
-
In 1953, Jewish gravestones were desecrated. Many families left for India, then Israel.
-
By 1968, the Jewish population of Karachi had dropped to under 250. By 1980s, it was almost zero.
Then in 1988, under Zia-ul-Haq’s Islamization wave, Magain Shalome — the last physical sign of Karachi’s Jewish presence — was demolished to build a shopping plaza. Few protested.
From Neighbors to “Zionists”
How did neighbors become enemies?
-
State media began referring to Jews only as Zionists.
-
The Arab-Israeli wars of 1956, 1967, and 1973 triggered street protests in Pakistan, often targeting local Jewish symbols.
-
Islamist groups declared the Jewish cemetery “enemy territory.” Even today, it remains locked, guarded by a single Muslim caretaker, and rarely visited.
-
A new identity was forged: Pakistani = anti-Zionist. Jewish = traitor.
And so the Karachi Jews vanished.
What Remains?
-
The Jewish cemetery still exists behind the Gora Qabristan, though neglected.
-
The Solomon David family archives survive in fragments, scattered across London, Tel Aviv, and Mumbai.
-
Some families changed their names and stayed behind, passing as Parsis or Christians.
-
Karachi’s old municipal records still show Jewish births, marriages, and land titles.
But to most Karachiites today, the Jewish past is either a rumor — or a conspiracy theory.
Voices from the Exodus
“We were not Israel. We were Karachiites.” — Ruth David, former resident of Pakistan, now living in Israel
“I played cricket with Muslim boys. We never spoke of religion. Then suddenly, I was a foreigner.” — Joseph Moses, via Jewish Chronicle
Post a Comment