A boy in uniform salutes the Israeli flag while his grandmother, wrapped in a faded shawl from Gondar, stands behind him with tears in her eyes. He is Ethiopian. She is proud. And yet, even in that moment of belonging, something lingers. Something unsaid.
Maybe this is what integration looks like: uniforms, Hebrew fluency, and youth protests sparked by police bullets.
Maybe that’s the tragedy too.
You ever wonder how a country born from persecution can build its own ladders of exclusion?
When Justice Wears a Kippah but Looks Away
Let’s talk about success—because it’s always the counterpoint, isn’t it?
“But look,” someone says, “that Ethiopian girl just became a judge.”
True. But what of the dozens of Ethiopian teenagers locked away for petty crimes at rates three times higher than their peers?
And sure, Mizrahi music plays in Tel Aviv clubs. But whose accent do newscasters still mimic when they want to sound "uncultured"?
Israel's founders dreamed of ingathering exiles—Jews of all colors and customs. But not all exiles were welcomed equally. Ashkenazim (European Jews) became the architects. Mizrahim (Jews from Arab lands) were assigned the guest rooms. Ethiopians? Sometimes, they were made to knock twice.
In the 1990s, Israel’s national blood bank was found to have been quietly discarding blood donations from Ethiopians—for fear of HIV. No press release. No apology. Just a silent verdict that echoed: "Your blood isn't good enough."
The Mizrahi Majority That Still Feels Peripheral
Now here’s a twist: Mizrahim aren’t a minority in Israel. They’re the majority.
And still, they earn 36% less on average than Ashkenazim. A Mizrahi resume gets fewer callbacks. And the university halls remain disproportionately Ashkenazi.
How did a people who carried Arabic lullabies, Persian poems, and North African cuisine into Israel end up being told to drop their “Arab habits”?
Ben Gurion once dismissed Moroccan Jews as “primitive.” Policy followed prejudice. Arabic was discouraged, French was fine. Middle Eastern customs were exoticized, then erased.
Traditional Yemeni dance became “Israeli folk dance.” Not Yemeni. Not Arab. Just… assimilated.
Echoes from Karachi, Dhaka, and Kabul
If you're South Asian, this all sounds familiar.
Ahmadis in Pakistan. Chakma tribes in Bangladesh. Hazaras in Afghanistan. Every post-colonial state inherits fault lines—and often deepens them.
Israel privileged its European Jews just as our own post-Partition elites favored Urdu-speaking migrants or those with colonial-era diplomas. It's not about religion. It's about who speaks the “right” language, wears the “right” clothes, eats the “right” food.
It’s why an Ethiopian Israeli might distance himself from African asylum seekers. Why a Mizrahi youth might lean harder into Israeli nationalism—just to prove he’s not “Arab.”
Because when the state says, “We’re all Jews here,” it doesn’t always say it equally.
Beyond the ‘Apartheid’ Frame
Here’s where it gets tricky. Is this apartheid?
Not in the South African sense. Ethiopian and Mizrahi Jews are citizens. They vote. They serve in the army. Some rise to high office.
But scratch beneath the surface and you’ll find softer walls—less visible, but just as real. Cultural exclusion. Bureaucratic cold shoulders. Ashkenazi dominance in media, academia, and the rabbinate.
That’s not apartheid. But it is discrimination. And it demands a reckoning.
Seeds of Change, But Will They Grow?
Some signs offer hope.
Ethiopian officers now command army units. Mizrahi chefs are reclaiming pride in their culinary heritage. Activists are louder. Protests more visible.
But systems are stubborn. A state that questions the Judaism of Ethiopian elders or marginalizes Mizrahi prayer traditions isn't just being bureaucratic. It’s sending a message: there’s a hierarchy here. You’re in it. But not on top.
Final Thought: The Danger of Simple Stories
We want our stories to be clean. Israel is either a refuge or a colonizer. Mizrahim are either fully Israeli or forever outsiders. Ethiopians are either victims or success stories.
But life isn’t binary. It's layered. And acknowledging injustice doesn’t mean denying belonging.
Maybe the better question isn’t: “Is Israel racist?”
Maybe it’s: “How can any society born of trauma avoid reproducing it?”
South Asians should ask the same. We've done it too.
Because in the end, building a just society isn’t about purity. It’s about courage—especially the courage to see your own reflection in the eyes of those you once othered.
Then again, maybe silence says enough.
Comments
Post a Comment