Justice Has No Flag: Why War Crimes Are War Crimes — No Matter Who Commits Them
After my last piece on October 7, someone left a comment that stopped me mid-scroll. “It takes being a real human to write something like this,” they said. Then they added something I’ve been thinking about ever since: “Hamas attacking soldiers and taking POWs are not war crimes. All civilian killings are potential war crimes. Targeting civilians and taking civilian hostages is absolutely a war crime. Hamas definitely committed war crimes on Oct. 7. Israel has been committing war crimes since 1948. That does not justify Hamas committing war crimes. Which also means that Israel has no justification for committing war crimes after Oct. 7. Those crimes include attacking anyone inside Gaza, as it is Israeli-occupied territory.” That comment said, in a few tight lines, what whole conferences and TV panels have failed to say: that justice cannot wear a uniform. The Law of the Unequal I have spent the past year watching a strange inversion unfold. The side that speaks of resist...