When the Taliban returned to power in August 2021, they promised a softer rule. Four years later, their actions show something else. Women in Afghanistan are banned from secondary schools and universities. They cannot work in most jobs. Aid agencies are told not to employ them. These are the harshest restrictions on women anywhere in the Muslim world.
Is This Sharia or a Misuse of It?
The Taliban claim these rules come from sharia. But Muslim scholars across the world disagree.
-
Sheikh Abdullah bin Bayyah, a leading jurist from Mauritania, has said: “There is no basis in Islam to deny women education. Knowledge is an obligation, not a privilege.”
-
The Egyptian scholar Sheikh Muhammad al-Ghazali once wrote: “When you educate a man, you educate one person. When you educate a woman, you educate a generation.”
-
The Qur’an itself commands: “Are those who know equal to those who do not know?” (39:9). This verse is not limited to men.
History supports this view. The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ himself said: “Seeking knowledge is obligatory on every Muslim.” His wife Aisha taught companions and became one of the most respected scholars of her time. Fatima al-Fihri, a Muslim woman, founded the world’s first university in Fez in 859.
If Islam allowed women to teach, trade, and lead in earlier centuries, what justifies banning them now? The issue is not sharia but the Taliban’s cultural interpretation, which confuses local custom with divine law.
Life for Afghan Women at Home
So what happens when women are confined indoors? Families often claim they will protect their daughters, sisters, and wives. Fathers provide food. Brothers guard them. Husbands say they offer care.
But protection without freedom is another form of captivity. A woman may be safe from hunger but not from despair. She may have shelter but no dignity. Peace that depends only on male guardianship leaves her powerless to build her own life.
Women in the West: More Freedom, More Strain
Across America and Europe, women’s lives look very different. They study freely, work in all fields, and make personal choices. In many ways, this is closer to Islam’s vision of education and dignity.
Yet the West has its own struggles. Divorce rates are high. In the United States, around 40–45% of marriages end in divorce (CDC, 2023). In Europe, the rate varies: nearly 50% in the UK, and over 60% in some Nordic states. Many women raise children alone. In the U.S., about 24% of children live with a single parent, the highest rate in the world (Pew Research, 2019).
Freedom can bring independence but also loneliness. Women work, but many speak of burnout, broken families, and weak support systems.
Which Life Is Peaceful?
The Afghan woman at home may appear “protected,” but her peace is fragile. It relies on men in her family and leaves her no space to grow. The Western woman has freedom, but her family life is often unstable. She may be independent yet isolated.
Neither model is truly peaceful. Afghan society needs to restore women’s right to education and work. Western societies need to rebuild family bonds so that freedom does not come at the price of isolation.
The Balance Missing
Islam already offers this balance. It commands both family care and women’s dignity. It praises knowledge, protects rights, and upholds justice. The Qur’an says: “Do not forget your share of the world” (28:77). That applies equally to women and men.
The truth is clear. One world guards family but silences women. The other empowers women but often weakens family. Real peace will come when dignity and family strength stand together.
Comments
Post a Comment